I really need to learn not to read things that will ruffle my feathers before I work.
My mind was having irrational yelling matches at the stupid people's comments, and the worst part: These people will never hear my rant, and they will never change their opinion... because they are just silly like that.
What did I read, you ask? I was on MSN.com and there was an article that says "NYC student arrested for Doodling on desk". It of course caught my interest.
The gist of the story is that a 12 year old girl in NY doodled "Lex was here 2/1/10" and "I love my friends Abby and Faith" on her school desk. This girl got arrested, handcuffed, and drug down to the police station. Her punishment: 8 hours of community service, a book report, and an essay on what she learned from this experience.
I decided to hop on over to the "discuss this story" link . I was shocked at the comments! People were sticking up for the girl. They were bashing the school officer, the police station, and saying that a lawsuit needs to be made... because it was wrongful to do that to a kid.
Um..... Hello?
The girl was vandalizing school property. Vandalizing something is a crime. Black and White. No where does it say that it's only considered bad graffiti if it doesn't have happy sayings and drawings of unicorns on it. (She didn't draw a unicorn, I am trying to make a point.)
When are people going to step up and realize that if we teach our kids lessons of right and wrong... that maybe, just maybe, our criminal justice system wouldn't be such a joke. Just Maybe our jail cells wouldn't be over stuffed and using up our tax dollars.
Case and Point:
When my brother was about 9 years old, he stole candy bars from K-Mart. My mom found the wrappers in his room days later. The first step she took was to bring my brother to K-Mart, where he had to apologize for stealing, and then made to pay the price of the candy bars. The second place she took my brother? Jail. Yep. Jail. (She had connections, as she was a dispatcher for the state police.) The officers took him through the booking process, brought him back to a jail cell and made him sit in it.
I was about 7 when all this happened, and I remember my brother crying so hard that he had a bloody nose. You want to know what my brother and I learned? Stealing is a crime. If you are a thief, you will go to jail. End of story.
Guess what? Neither my brother or I have ever stolen again. It put quite an impression on me about the rules and about laws. My brother and I have grown up to be law abiding citizens and we are responsible parents to our children and teach them the lessons of right and wrong.
Now days if some parent did what my mother did, I'm sure that Child Protective Services would be called... as it would be considered 'abusive'.
(I am also in no way saying that if your kid does something wrong it's an immediate trip to the police station..... make sure of the point and lesson you want to teach your kid, and follow through. I have yet to bring Alli to the police station for hitting her sister.... although, it could be on my list one day... hehe)
I think that this girl's parents should be thankful that people actually cared enough to punish her, and teach her those lessons. I also think those 8 hours of community service should be spent in the school cleaning off every single desk spic and span... (after all, the punishment needs to fit the crime.)
Anyway, I spent the whole car ride to work yelling (in my head) at the people making comments on that post. Then when I got to work, I had to vent to my co-workers. Luckily I have co-workers that agreed with me 110%, so that helped some of the anger go away.
Goosfraba (repeat 3 times)
{that's from the movie 'Anger Management}
Think about what would you have done if :
A) This was your kid.
B) You were the teacher.
or
C) You were the officer at the school.
Saturday, February 6, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)



7 comments:
I'm more into letting the punishment fit the crime. Handcuffing a 12-year-old girl and taking her to a police staion? That's something I would expect done to someone who was a)hurting someone, or b)planning on hurting someone.
It was a freaking desk. Have her pay for a new one. It was vandalism. Have her learn about what vandalism does to our community- yes with community service.
But the handcuffing and police station were comletely unwarranted, and deserved the attention of the populus, because that situation was indeed handled poorly.
I totally agree that many kids today are not required to "pay" for their crimes and in turn this leads to much bigger problems for our society...I see it all the time in my school. However, in this case it does seem like cops and handcuffs is going to the extreme! (btw I love that your mom took scott to jail...and if this girls parents wanted to teach her a lesson I think they should have done that) Heres what I did as a teacher...last year when I was sick and had a sub in my classroom I had two 2nd grade boys purposely breaking pens and then pouring the ink out onto the carpet. I was so mad when I returned and discovered their mess! I wrote them up, they spent detention time with the principal and the parents were all contacted. I decided they needed a little more to really get the point and so I required them to stay in at recess for a day to scrub that carpet. One of the parents blew it off and kept her son home to prevent him from this additional punishment! The other family made their son break his piggy bank, took him to the store to buy, with his own money, carpet cleaner, rubber gloves, scrub brushes, and towels. They then gave me permission to keep him in at EVERY recess until the stain was out (which it never will be because it was permenant ink---and the parents said that might just be the thing that would teach him a lesson!). THis year as 3rd graders kid number one is still a total trouble maker, and kid number two has made huge gains in improving his behavior issues. I think the punishment NEEDS to fit the crime for kids to see the effects of their actions and be aware of how they impact others.
Yikes! I'm a little scared to disagree, I don't want you to hate me. ;) For this particular situation of writing on a school desk... I think everyone I knew when I was in school wrote on our desks. I can see it now. We all did it. So, to be handcuffed and drug off to jail for it? I think it's a little excessive for what she did. However, I think what your mom did with your brother was a very smart thing and he learned a very good lesson. I'm sure that if Emma had that done to her for doodling on a desk, I would be furious. For this offense, I think the appropriate punishment would be detention. And during detention, she should have to scrub desks, but jail? For this? No. Not in my opinion.
Okay, I meant to write, "I'm sure that if Emma had gone to jail for doodling on her desk, I would be furious." oops that's what I get for not proofreading.
I think Summer has totally taken the words right out of my mouth. They have principals for a reason.The police being in the school is to protect my child from those who could harm them or others not for a child who was obviously bored and wanted to color..Let's put it in a bit different perspective..your child decides to color on your walls do you call the police and have them arrested for "graffit'ing" your house? No you make the child wash the walls and probably ground them from crayons for a week. I would be a very upset parent if I found out my child was cuffed for that..Heck Adrian just did a similar thing at school and he didn't get arrested he had a huge stern talking to with me and he was not allowed to do certain activities but I did not take him downtown to be arrested for graffiti.. It all matters on your perspective..
Ok, here's my little say. Yes, the punishment should fit the crime, and (sorry Breezi!) I think the police bit was over the top. HOWEVER. I also know that children are individuals, with their own personalities, and their own home situations. Some kids who are not taught by their parents have no clue about acceptable behavior. I have to remind myself about this when dealing with some of my kids' friends.
Also, there can be a huge difference as to what will make an impression on different children. I have one that will burst into tears if I just raise my voice at her, and another who said, (and I quote!)"THAT didn't hurt." and remained defiant when I gave him a sound spanking.
Let the punishment fit not only the crime, but also the child.
Post a Comment