Thursday, December 10, 2009

The Great Santa Debate

I have always assumed that most little children believe in Santa.

I assumed wrong.

When asking a little girl who was at my teller window yesterday what Santa is going to bring her she said "Mommy and Daddy buy me presents. Santa is the Devil." She was only 3.

Talk about being blown away!

Her comments started a debate among my co-workers and (known) customers alike. I am surprised at the amount of parents who tell their children straight up that Santa isn't real, Mommy and Daddy buy the presents. Santa is just made up because Retail stores want to sell things. Through the discussions most of the parents' reasons of not letting their children believe are selfish -they want their children to know that they bought the presents, and they want to get all of that credit, or unfounded -They think that if they let their kids believe in Santa that the kids won't know about the real reason for the season, which of course is Jesus, or these parents just flat up think that you shouldn't let your kids believe in a lie.

I want my children to have the opportunity to believe in the magic of Christmas. To believe in the magic and wonderment of Santa. Christmas is a time of giving and good cheer. It's not a time of selfish recognition. Doing for others doesn't mean taking all the credit.

I brought it up to my co-worker that if she chooses to let her kid know the truth about Santa, that she also needs to teach her young child some discretion. Her child is going to be the one that makes all the other kindergartners cry by telling them Santa isn't real. My co-worker said that she's not going to tell her child to do that, that she should be able to tell the other kids what she believes in. I feel sorry for all of her kids' future classmates.

I personally don't think there is anything wrong with letting kids believe in Santa as long as you teach your children about Jesus and the reason behind Christmas. I think Chip and I have done a pretty good job about telling our kids about Jesus- all about His birth and the miracles behind it, and also about His ministries. My children love playing with the different Nativities we have and reenacting the story. My children also believe in the magic of Santa. At our home he only fills our stockings. My kids can't wait to see what he'll bring. I don't think my children will need therapy because we let them believe in a 'lie'. I think they'd need more therapy if we told them where babies really come from and how they are made.


What are your feelings with letting your kids believe or not believe in Santa?

15 comments:

Valerie said...

Santa doesn't visit our house on Christmas...Now hear me out. I want Christmas to be about Jesus but Santa (Saint Nick) was quite the man. He visits our house on Dec. 6th Saint Nicks day. We make gingerbread houses and talk about how we can help others like Saint Nick did. In Ben's mind Santa is real, he just happens to love Jesus and helping others. I love the "meaning" of Santa so much and the miracle of him helping others - that's what Christmas is all about, Jesus came for others ...

Megan said...

This is actaully something I struggle with. Our kids do believe in Santa but we don't make a huge deal about him. He brings them a few things to fill up the stockings on Christmas morning(and that's it). We rarely even "go see" Santa. I love the magic and excitement about it... I just don't like the idea of it being the most importand part.
On another point though. My cousins grow up very strict missouri senate Lutheran and their parents decided to leave Santa out of Christmas. However, they were taught not to tell other children and they understood his importance to other people. Even though they knew he wasn't real... they still enjoyed all of the stories, movies and even just the thought of him. But if you think about, we know that Santa isn't real, and yet we still get all squishy inside when we watch some heartwarming Sants movie.

Rachel Holloway said...

It's a tough call, huh? I don't like the idea of outright telling kids its fake, but we definitely don't put a lot of emphasis on him. But I do love the magic that comes with it... :)

Lora said...

My sister-in-law and her family do not do the Santa thing and at first I was fine with it, because Grace was only 1 when we spent a Christmas with them. Now, it is a different story. Now that Grace is older, her cousins could and have spilled the beans. They have been "taught" not to tell children the truth, but that is hard for children who were raised to always tell the truth. Luckly the few times it was spilled it went over Grace's head and never thought of again. I think without Santa there is definatly majic left out of Christmas. I am with you on not putting so much emphasis on him as much as we should put on the Savior. That is why I LOVE the First Presidency's Christmas Devotional every year!! It is something I look forward too and it sets Christmas up so perfectly! We can all get caught up in the commercialism of Christmas, but I don't think that was how Santa got started. He was about giving and that is the part that should be focused on! We are about to spend another Christmas with my Sister-in-law and I'm dreading the cousins spilling the beans. This year I don't think it will go over Grace's head like it has done. Any suggestions on how to ease the blow?

Marsie Pants said...

I have honestly never even thought about thinking of leaving Santa out of Christmas. I had no idea it was such a hot issue. This whole post just blows my mind.

Lisa said...

I am definitely for making sure there is a balance and teaching our children about the true meaning of Christmas but letting our children believe in the magic as well; I remember how exciting that was. You are only a child once and it can be so magical. Before you know it they will know the truth. Also, at our home Santa fills the stocking and gives them one small gift.

Amandean said...

Simple theory: Santa is a fun, magical part of Christmas and childhood. Christ is the reason for the season. Why not have both?

Jodi said...

I've always loved the idea of Santa and always will! It was a magical part of Christmas and yet thinking back, Jesus was just as big of a part for me...I think you can have a good balance of the two. Also, it may sound odd, but I think Santa can teach a child faith. That may just sound wrong to some people but oh well!

Michelle said...

Wait there is no Santa?!!! Crap that means I need to go shopping soon!! lol

I wasn't going to pipe in but I guess I will share. Christmas is magical, it is fun, Santa makes part of it magical, Growing up it was all about Santa until we figured out their ain't no Santa. That doesn't mean Christmas can't still be magical..by doing Christlike services around Christmas I think it enhances the Reason for the Season. I will not share what we do just to keep the secret but our girls understand Santa and they also understand the reason for the season. Perfect balance.

Amanda B. said...

Wow- I found this shocking. A 3 year old saying Santa is the devil??? I understand if the parent doesn't want their child to believe in Santa, but that seems to be going a little far....

I am totally with you. There is no harm in it- it is magical and so fun for adults and kids. I grew up believe in Santa and I am (relatively) normal! ;) I also believe in Jesus- and teach my kids about him as well- around Christmas and year round! :) Interesting post!

Marilyn said...

I am also shocked that the Santa-devil idea came from a 3-year-old. Shocked, and sad. I'm pro-Santa, but we've taught our kids about Christ all their lives. They heard about Christ all year long, and only got Santa one month of the year (in addition to the Nativity story). Never took them to sit on his lap, but often took them to see the helicopter arrival at the mall. As they got older we didn't want them to burst anyone's bubble, so they were told if they stopped "believing" (wink, wink), then "Santa" wouldn't bring them anything. My teenagers are ALL still "believers". I go with my gut, and since Santa warms my heart, he is not bad. If more people were like Santa, the world would be a better place. (For what it's worth, my teens also believe in the Tooth Fairy and the Easter Bunny, too!) ;-D

Summer said...

Ha! That poor kid!

Mia knows how babies are made. She also knows every major organ in the body, though. It would seem kind of weird to purposefully leave out the penis and vagina. I think the earlier you tell them how bodies work, the less mystery (and unhealthy curiosity) is involved when they're older. She also knows that we only talk about our bodies with our family and the doctor- so don't worry- she won't be bringing it up to your kids. ;D

I just like that "how babies are made" (she doesn't know the word or Hollywood's version of "sex" yet) isn't any more taboo or evil to her mind than "how food turns to poop," or "how mommy's gallbladder got taken out." We described the sperm and egg with the same matter-of-factness we used to show her how to add ingredients to make cake batter.

And childhood belief in Santa is the least of our worries. Disney brainwashing our kids to think they have to be in a rock band or a princess when they "grow up-" now THAT's the devil.

Ruthie K said...

I feel all sorts of good about letting kids believe in Santa. For goodness sake, I think that we still get stuff from Santa! We aren't ever allowed to say that we don't believe in Santa. I mean, it's MEAN to ruin the magic for someone else.
Just because I believed in the Tooth Fairy, doesn't mean I didn't believe in going to the dentist. (That may not have been a comparable example, but I used it anyway)

Cari said...

If your going to leave out Santa, then you need to boy cott the toothfairy and Easter Bunny too! Magic is Magic, and imagination is the same. Parents should use their descretion, there comes a time when kids don't believe anymore, and are skeptical, but we leave it up to their imagination. We don't lie if they ask. We make sure they really want to know, and if they do then we tell them, and swear them to secrecy that it is our right as Parents, to be able to share the love in secret ways we only get a few chances to do like at Christmas! Our kids being older, and teens now STILL enjoy recieving their gifts from Santa, and always remember to tell their parents thank you, in secret! Just because we all choose to celebrate differently, doesn't give others the right to push their chosen beliefs on others who still "BELIEVE" in both the birth of the Savior and magic of Santa.

Personally, I love that it gives my kids a reason to behave 1 month out of the year!

TracieG said...

My 3 year old is afraid of Santa. Ever since she saw her first mall Santa and I asked if she wanted to sit on his lap so I could get a photo, she has been disturbed by the whole idea. That got me thinking. I have to admit that I don't want ANY stranger holding my daughter. I don't feel right about telling my child that a man in a red suit literally comes into our home on Christmas Eve while we are asleep and leaves gifts for her under the tree. It feels like a flat-out lie to me. We read books about Santa and watch shows with him in it, but she thinks of him as a character just like Dora or Tinkerbell... not an actual real-life person but still a fun part of Christmas celebrations. She LOVED Christmas this year, and was so excited and sparkly-eyed even though her gifts were just from Mom and Dad. It may be a harmless lie, but it's still a lie- and I couldn't bring myself to tell it. (Just my opinion.)